I just finished testing my 21x21 layout tonight and it works perfectly, however, yes, I find it to be too compressed and dirty. it even has a little distortion with the drive set at minimum and there was also some fizziness in the background of the clean signal. I fixed both of those problems on mine by substituting 3 resistor values.
here's a pic of my built up and tested circuit:
IMO, the 2K7 resistor coupling the buffer to pin 3 of the first 4558 was too low of a value, clipping the front end of the opamp. I replaced that one with a 10K and it removed the ugly distortion on the clean signal.
first, I tired two green leds in the first set of clipping diodes, but it actually sounded worse, and the diodes never really lit up, so, to give it less overall gain in order to be almost perfectly clean with the drive set fully CCW, I doubled the values of the two frequency gain resistors (the 1K connected to the 68n to a 2K and the 1K8 connected to the 2u2 to a 3K6). finally, instead of using a huge 470u filter cap, I used two 220u's in parallel to fit the board better. here's my final, and verified layout: