motterpaul wrote
... I looked at the tone 22n with a 50k pot, which seems to be a high pass filter (cap followed by resistor), and I tried a number of different caps in there and nothing changed. It seems that because it is a HPF lowering the corner frequency didn't add bass, it just seems to make it get less bright, but even with the tone full CCW it is too bright with any cap.
It's a cut-only high-shelf filter, just like a guitar tone knob. It bleeds treble to ground and leaves bass in the signal. Increasing either the cap value or the pot value will give more treble roll-off at full CCW, but should leave the EQ unaffected at full CW. Try a 100k pot or a 100n cap, if you haven't already. Go higher if necessary.
Because it's a shelving filter it reduces the high frequencies by a specific amount. At full CCW with high RC values, it will start to reduce bass as well. I low-pass filter would work better because it would reduce treble in proportion to frequency above the corner. So higher frequencies would be reduced even more.
None of these things will increase bass response though. And if the output is too shrill (rather than just too bright) then you might be better off cutting treble on the input side rather than the output side. Try turning down the tone knob on your guitar and see if that gets you closer to what you want. If so, you could put a low-pass filter on the circuit input to make it permanent.