Off board wiring is probably most likely.
The idea that there might be a short in the IC itself is very unlikely. Even after building dozens of pedals I still get a short in either my board from a solder bridge, something offboard touching, or a missed cut in the vero.
Despite this, if you are certain that it's the IC that's the problem, then the only solution would be to swap the IC.
When you get tired of swapping ICs, post up some photos.
Q: Why is a drummer like a scud missile?
A: Both are offensive and inaccurate.