Ouch, dud components are always the last thing you would expect.
Glad you got it working!
Mine is ticking in the square wave shape, but it works fine otherwise.
I have started to use shielded input/output wires for all my modulation builds..
Seems to help alot to reduce/eliminate ticking.
I wish I could understand programming, but it's way over my head.
But I have a friend who is helping me to make a custom PIC for my PWM phaser.
Looking forward to you report on the rotary switches!
I was also thinking of doing that with my cardial tremolo (+taplfo) build
check out my building blog at www.parasitstudio.se